Loading the calculator…
Chicago smart streetlights
Primary Results
Cost & Return Breakdown
What this scenario assumes / Why this result?
Editable estimates are illustrative unless identified as sourced. See the scenario sources for documented benchmarks.
Compare solar installations in the same state
These are independent presets at the selected state, horizon and discount rate. Edit comparison tariffs separately. Self-use offsets retail purchases, exports earn the export tariff. No tax credit, elective pay or battery resilience is assumed.
Illustrative electric savings sensitivity
Low, typical and high cases hold other inputs fixed. These are scenarios, not warranted savings. LBNL’s commissioning findings are not estimates for a new BMS.
Water utility · economics audit
Historical model note · superseded by v930
The former distribution-network presets used separate wear-part charges and escalated maintenance in addition to recurring network service. Those assumptions are not part of the v930 acoustic leak-detection preset. The current editable model uses one full-device renewal interval and includes routine upkeep in its single annual monitoring/communications expense. Customer metering remains a separate scenario.
Annual expenditures and savings · year one
Replacement and renewal costs
Network equipment renewal
The proposed full-device renewal interval and per-device cost are editable in Repairs, service & replacements. There is no separate monitor wear-service charge in the v930 default.
NPV drivers and break-even
Ranked by the change in owner NPV from increasing one current input or cost group by 10%, holding the rest fixed. Zero-value inputs have no change in this test.
Returns and sensitivity
Use local budget and water audit data. Avoid counting production, treatment or pumping twice. Routine visit costs already include travel. Keep claims and recovered bills out of societal benefits. Enter only independently supported conservation, vehicle externality or damage benefits that are not counted elsewhere.
Public economic value · not city revenue
Societal cost–benefit screening, discounted USD
Travel-time, road-user fuel, safety, clean air and climate impacts are valued separately from financial cash flow. Fees, grants, and credit receipts are transfers, not new resources for society.
Adaptive signals · travel-time and fuel sensitivity
Server-calculated public economic cases
These sensitivity results scale only the selected travel and fuel benefits while holding all other assumptions fixed. They are model cases, not measured outcomes. Traffic-based estimates use one deduplicated, nonoverlapping network volume.
Travel-time only
| Share of selected time benefit | Annual person-hours | Public NPV | BCR |
|---|
Combined time + fuel
| Share of selected benefits | Person-hours / gallons per year | Public NPV | BCR |
|---|
Break-even thresholds
The direct annual aggregate defaults remain selected to preserve the existing v933 benchmark results. Traffic-volume and operational-fuel modes are optional; their inputs are editable and begin at zero. Values entered for overlapping corridors must be deduplicated before entering a network total.
Smart Parking: financial and public value
Dynamic model results · year one unless stated otherwise
Operator financial effects
Driver and public effects
Financial return vs. total public economic value
Cumulative discounted net value, including year 0
The dashed line includes resource savings and monetized externalities and excludes transfers such as grants and parking payments. It can differ from owner NPV even if incremental external benefits are zero. Illustrative screening analysis, not an official cost–benefit analysis. No benefit is guaranteed; the public estimate should use local data and applicable government BCA guidance. The owner result remains unchanged by noncash benefits.
Cumulative public benefits
Gross discounted benefits start at zero. They include avoided baseline costs and positive public benefits before proposed costs are deducted. See public economic NPV for the net result.
When does it pay off?
Discounted cumulative advantage · USD (scaled by chart)
Year 0 includes upfront replacement investment net of incentives. Values above zero favor the proposed system. Financing is shown separately below to avoid double-counting capital.
Yearly net operating costs
Nominal USD · expenses net of eligible incremental receipts, including scheduled renewals
Most scenarios treat existing equipment as already owned. Fleet is an exception: both new alternatives are purchased in Year 0. Periodic parts and full renewals are modeled separately; an optional residual-value credit accounts for unused life beyond the horizon.
What drives total cost?
Gross discounted cost composition · shared zero-based scale
Bars show gross present-value expenditures before eligible incremental revenues or optional terminal asset credits; net TCO includes those credits. For most scenarios the baseline asset is already owned; the fleet scenario separately includes both new Year 0 purchases. Later renewals can affect either alternative. Financing appears separately below.
Environmental impact → dollars
Separate societal valuation · not cash savings
New income and avoided operating losses
Modeled as cash only when it accrues to the project owner
Asset life & planned renewals
Age-related maintenance and reinvestment
Calculating replacement schedule…
Scheduled replacement events
Service life is not a guarantee. A 10-year decision can understate longer-term savings, while a 25–50-year model needs one or more replacement cycles. A credit for remaining asset life at the cutoff year is optional and is not assumed to be cash received.
Financing & cash requirements
Equity and debt · separate from economic TCO
The model treats a loan as upfront financing inflow and subsequent annual debt payments; it does not count borrowed principal as an extra project cost. A remaining loan balance is paid at the horizon in the model.
Discount-rate sensitivity
Compare the selected rate with rates two percentage points lower and higher, within the supported range. All other assumptions stay fixed.
| Discount rate | Financial NPV | Public economic NPV |
|---|
Annual calculation table
Review and export the numbers
| Year | Baseline alternative cost | Proposed alternative cost | Major renewals | Annual savings | Cumulative discounted benefit | CO₂e avoided |
|---|
Figures rounded for display. Downloaded CSV contains unrounded calculations and year-specific inputs.
Research behind the starting templates
Evidence versus assumptions
The project scale and selected cost/energy benchmarks below are sourced. Unless explicitly marked, preset financial assumptions are illustrations, not measured performance or procurement prices. Energy tariffs, incentives, loan terms, solar output, occupancy gains and maintenance costs should be replaced with local figures for investment decisions.
USDOT guidance can inform public benefit valuation but this tool does not claim approved USDOT unit values. The carbon price is user-selected, not necessarily recommended by any agency. 2025 electricity prices are historical state averages. Inputs are sent to the SCD server for calculation.
How to read the results
Model boundaries & assumptions
Financial TCO: discounted capital, electricity, annual maintenance, truck rolls, network subscriptions, periodic component replacements and scheduled full-asset renewals, minus upfront incentives and any explicitly selected residual values. A positive financial benefit means the proposed system costs less over the chosen horizon.
Financing: the baseline comparison is unlevered. If you enter a loan, a separate cash-flow calculation shows your upfront equity, payments, and any unpaid balance due at the end of the horizon. Financing does not create savings.
Public economics: estimated NPV adds monetized noncash benefits (traveler time, third-party fuel, avoided crashes, local pollution, and climate) to real operating resource savings. It excludes upfront grants and modeled gross parking fees, solar export payments, and verified environmental credits because these are primarily transfers between participants. Fuel savings already reflected in owner expenses should NOT be entered again as public road-user fuel. Carbon damages are independent of saleable credits. This is a screening approximation, not a certified USDOT BCA; avoid double counting and calibrate to local conditions.
Environment: avoided kWh × an editable emissions factor, declining if you select grid decarbonization. The estimate subtracts embodied emissions for initial new assets and later proposed renewals, counts any avoided emissions from full baseline renewals, PV exports, and separately entered combustion emissions. The climate-dollar estimate is discounted separately; it is not automatically recognized revenue.
Scope: screening-level planning, not a bid estimate, formal lifecycle assessment, safety assessment, or a guarantee of equipment service life. It excludes taxes, probabilistic asset survival, tariff demand charges, uncertain contract incentives, and unverified economic externalities unless explicitly entered. A 50-year projection is highly speculative and should be used for sensitivity analysis, not as a claim that one installation lasts 50 years. Update assumptions with local data before decisions.
The Chicago reference
Case study + editable assumptionsChicago's 2017 streetlight modernization program initially targeted approximately 270,000 high-pressure sodium fixtures for LED conversion with networked lighting controls. Later Department of Energy descriptions report more than 280,000 HPS fixtures replaced at completion in 2022. This prototype deliberately uses the 270,000 planning-scale scenario.
Program sources describe a roughly 50% or greater reduction in energy use and projected electricity savings of about $100 million over ten years. These are reported program figures, not outputs reconstructed from Chicago invoices here.
U.S. Department of Energy — original Chicago program scope · DOE — 2022 completion case study · Ameresco — project and reported electricity savings
Electricity-related emissions depend on the regional grid and the assessment method. The example's factor is explicitly illustrative and editable. For real assessments, use a documented regional grid factor and distinguish average emissions accounting from avoided marginal emissions. EPA — electricity emissions methodology.
Chicago's actual procurement prices, current tariffs, incentive contracts, maintenance cost structure, embodied carbon, and financing details are not inferred from the public summaries. Their prefilled values are hypothetical demonstration inputs; they should not be cited as Chicago's realized TCO.